Metrics Matter – Get the Full Picture

In a world obsessed with quick glances and snapshots, it’s easy to miss the forest for the trees, especially when it comes to investing. Welcome back to TappAlpha Trends, where today, we’re diving deep into the realm of investment metrics, specifically dissecting the allure of “yields” and why they’re only a part of the investment story. Our journey will unveil why understanding total returns—capital growth plus yield—is crucial for getting the full financial picture.

The Yields Mirage

Imagine you’re choosing a new car based on three key metrics: fuel efficiency, maintenance costs, and resale value. Focusing solely on fuel efficiency for its promise of savings is like an investor only eyeing yield—it’s tempting but incomplete. Just as a car’s maintenance costs and resale value are crucial for long-term satisfaction and value, in investing, capital growth alongside yield paints the full picture of an investment’s true worth. Opting for a vehicle—or an investment—based solely on one appealing metric can lead to overlooked risks and lost opportunities for greater, more comprehensive returns.

This analogy mirrors the investment world, where funds often only focus on yields as “the” metric. Yields, or the income returned on an investment, such as interest or dividends, are indeed attractive. They’re the immediate, tangible rewards of investing. However, seeing the full picture can help you make an informed decision.

Capital Growth + Yield = Total Returns

To truly understand an investment’s value, we must consider two primary components: capital growth and yield (we’ll talk tax in a future installment). These elements combine to form the concept of total returns, a metric that provides a comprehensive view of an investment’s performance.

  • Capital Growth: This is the appreciation (or depreciation) of the investment’s value over time. If you buy a stock at $100 and it rises to $110 over a year, the capital growth is 10%.
  • Yield: This is the income generated from the investment, often expressed as a percentage of he investment’s cost. If the same $100 stock mentioned above pays $4 in dividends annually, the yield is 4%.

Total Returns = Capital Growth + Yield. It’s the sum total of how much your investment has grown (or shrunk) plus the income it’s generated. In the example above, the total returns sum to 14%.

The Full Picture

Let’s say you’re considering two investments based on their yields. Investment A boasts an 8% yield, while Investment B offers a more modest 4% yield. On the surface, Investment A seems the clear winner. But let’s apply our total returns formula:

  • Investment A yields 8%, but the capital growth is -10% (perhaps the market is reacting to some adverse news). Your total return is -2%.
  • Investment B yields 4%, with capital growth at +5%. Your total return is 9%. Despite its lower yield, Investment B is the superior choice in terms of total returns.


Why It Matters

Understanding total returns is crucial for several reasons:

  • Risk Assessment: It helps investors gauge the risk and volatility of an investment beyond the allure of high yields.
  • Long-Term Planning: For those building wealth over time, focusing on total returns helps provide a more complete picture from which to make decisions.
  • Informed Decisions: Investors armed with total returns insights are better equipped to compare choices holistically, avoiding the pitfalls of yield-chasing.


Crafting Your Strategy

Recognizing the importance of total returns is one thing; applying this knowledge to your investment strategy is another. Here’s how you can start:

  • Diversify: Ensure your portfolio includes a mix of investments with varying yields and capital growth potentials to balance risk and reward.
  • Research: Look beyond the advertised yields. Investigate the factors influencing an investment’s capital growth prospects, like market trends and company performance.
  • Consult: Don’t hesitate to seek advice from financial professionals who can provide deeper insights into the total returns of potential investments.


The Check-Writing Analogy

Let’s circle back to our initial example: if an investment yields 8% but experiences a 10% decline in capital growth, you’re effectively losing more money than you’re making. It’s like paying someone to write you a check from your own account—you end up with less than you started. You’d be better off writing yourself a check for a smaller amount and keeping the rest invested in a more stable, growth-oriented opportunity.

In Conclusion

If investing were a gourmet meal, yield might be the eye-popping appetizer that draws you in, but it’s the main course—capital growth—that should also be on the table, providing a key component for a fulfilling financial journey. Together, they create the complete dining experience of total returns, blending the immediate gratification of yield with the satisfaction of growth. By considering the full picture, investors can savor a well-rounded meal tailored to their long-term financial palate.

At TappAlpha, we believe in empowering investors with the knowledge to see beyond the surface, to understand the mechanics behind the numbers, and to navigate the investment landscape with confidence. Let’s keep learning, growing, and investing wisely together.

You are now leaving the TappAlpha website

The following link may contain information concerning investments, products or other information.

Please click “continue” to leave this website and proceed to the selected site.

You are now leaving the TappAlpha website

The following link may contain information concerning investments, products or other information.

Please click “continue” to leave this website and proceed to the selected site.